Shopify vs WooCommerce: True Three-Year TCO at 600 Orders a Month
At 600 orders a month and a ₹1,800 average order value, Shopify costs 2.49% of revenue and WooCommerce 0.90%. Here is the full stack, and what the 1.59 point gap does not include.
At 600 orders a month and a ₹1,800 average order value, monthly revenue is ₹10,80,000. Shopify costs about ₹26,909 a month — 2.49% of revenue — and WooCommerce about ₹9,750, or 0.90%. Over three years that is ₹9,68,712 versus ₹3,51,000: a ₹6,17,712 gap that WooCommerce only keeps if nobody is paid to maintain it.
Formula
TCO = Subscription + Apps/Plugins + Transaction fees + Maintenance labour + One-off build · Express monthly, then annualise · Shopify: ₹1,917 + ₹3,500 + ₹21,492 = ₹26,909 · WooCommerce: ₹750 + ₹1,000 + ₹8,000 = ₹9,750
Transaction fees are the swing factor: they scale with revenue while subscriptions do not.
The comparison founders usually make is plan price against hosting price, which is the smallest line in either stack. Shopify's floor is the plan plus apps plus its payment fee; WooCommerce's floor is hosting plus plugins plus the hours a developer bills to keep WordPress, PHP and plugin updates from breaking checkout. Only one of those scales with revenue.
The monthly stack, line by line
| Line | Shopify | WooCommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Platform / hosting | ₹1,917 | ₹750 |
| Apps or plugins | ₹3,500 | ₹1,000 |
| Transaction fee | ₹21,492 (1.99%) | ₹0 |
| Maintenance labour | ₹0 | ₹8,000 |
| Monthly total | ₹26,909 | ₹9,750 |
| Share of revenue | 2.49% | 0.90% |
| Three-year total | ₹9,68,712 | ₹3,51,000 |
What the gap does not include
The ₹6,17,712 advantage is before three costs that fall almost entirely on WooCommerce. Checkout conversion is the first: managed checkout on Shopify reliably converts better than a plugin stack on shared hosting, and at ₹10,80,000 of monthly revenue a 0.3 percentage point conversion difference is ₹3,240 a month in forgone revenue. Security patching is the second: WooCommerce runs on PHP and a plugin ecosystem with a continuous CVE stream, and one compromised checkout during a festive sale costs more than three years of savings. Founder attention is the third, and it is the most expensive input in any bootstrapped business.
| Factor | Favours | Swing |
|---|---|---|
| Order volume above 2,000/mo | WooCommerce | Transaction fee dominates |
| Founder hour valued above ₹2,000 | Shopify | Maintenance labour cost |
| Conversion above +0.3 pp | Shopify | Revenue, not cost |
| Custom pricing and B2B | WooCommerce | No app tax |
| Multi-currency international | Shopify | Native presentment |
The RTO adjustment nobody models
Indian ecommerce carries a return-to-origin rate that materially changes platform economics, because gateway fees are charged on the gross transaction and refunds do not return the fee. At a 22% RTO rate, 1.99% on collected revenue is effectively 2.55% on net realised revenue. Always run platform comparisons on net realised revenue after RTO and refunds, not gross GMV — the ranking rarely flips, but the magnitude of the gap changes by a third.
A defensible way to decide
- Model both on net realised revenue after RTO, not GMV.
- Price the founder's or developer's hour explicitly, at market rate, even if unpaid today.
- Assume at least one security incident per three years on self-hosted and cost it.
- Run the decision at 2× current volume — platforms are chosen for the business you will have, not the one you have.
- Treat any migration as a one-off ₹40,000–₹80,000 cost plus two weeks of lost selling time.
Questions founders actually ask
Is WooCommerce really cheaper than Shopify?
On subscription and plugin cash, yes — roughly ₹3.51 lakh against ₹9.69 lakh over three years at 600 orders a month. That advantage disappears once maintenance labour is priced at market rates above about 16 hours a month.
At what order volume does Shopify become expensive?
Above roughly 2,000 orders a month. Shopify charges a percentage transaction fee on top of the plan, so cost rises with revenue while WooCommerce's hosting and plugin costs stay largely flat.
Does Shopify charge a transaction fee if I use Razorpay?
Yes. Using a third-party gateway instead of Shopify Payments typically attracts an additional fee of around 2% on Shopify plans in India, which is often more than the gateway's own charge.
How long does a WooCommerce to Shopify migration take?
Two to four weeks for a catalogue under 2,000 SKUs, including redirect mapping. Budget ₹40,000–₹80,000 for the build and expect two weeks of degraded selling time around the cutover.
Which is better for a D2C brand in India?
Shopify below about ₹1 crore of annual GMV, because conversion, checkout reliability and UPI support are worth more than the fee. Above ₹5 crore, self-hosted or headless becomes worth the engineering cost as the percentage fee dominates.