Full-Time Hire vs Agency vs AI Modeler
The real comparison is not salary against retainer. It is three-year total cost of ownership: a hire carries recruiting, statutory contributions, equipment and a management tax; an agency carries a markup and hidden coordination cost; an AI-plus-freelancer stack carries tooling and supervision. This engine prices all three on the same timeline.
Lowest three-year total cost of ownership across the three routes.
—
- Cheapest
- Mid
- Most expensive
—
—
—
- Cheapest path
- Most expensive path
The math, benchmarks & FAQs
All three paths are annualised to the same horizon and include the costs founders usually leave out: statutory load and recruiting for a hire, markup for an agency, supervision for the AI stack.
hireTCO = salary × (1 + statutory) × years + recruit + equip × years + management agencyTCO = retainer × 12 × years × (1 + markup) aiTCO = tools × 12 × years + freelanceHours × rate × 12 × years + supervision cheapest = min(hireTCO, agencyTCO, aiTCO) delta = nextCheapest − cheapest
- statutory
- Employer-side PF at 12%, ESI where applicable, gratuity at 4.81%, plus insurance. About 18% on top of CTC for most Indian companies.
- management
- The founder or manager hours consumed by hiring, reviewing and retaining a person. Priced at your own internal rate.
- markup
- Agency margin over the cost of the work. 35–60% is standard for Indian digital agencies.
| Cost line | Typical value | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Employer statutory load | 16 – 20% on CTC | PF 12% + gratuity 4.81% + ESI + insurance. Frequently omitted from founder comparisons. |
| Recruiting cost | 8.33% of first-year CTC | Standard Indian agency fee is one month of salary, or 8.33%. |
| Ramp time to productivity | 3 – 6 months | A hire's first quarter is a cost with partial output. Agencies start billing immediately. |
| Agency markup over cost | 35 – 60% | The margin you are paying for coordination and continuity. |
| AI-assisted output reliability | 70 – 85% first draft | Means 15–30% of the work still needs a human, which is the freelance line in this model. |
| Benchmarks are directional guides, not rules of law. Stage, sector and gross margin move the frontier. | ||
The comparison is not like for like, and that is the point
A hire gives you capacity that compounds: domain knowledge, relationships and reliability that survive the project. An agency gives you a senior team immediately and none of it becomes yours. An AI stack gives you speed on well-specified work and nothing at all on ambiguous work. The TCO tells you which is cheapest; the strategic question is which of those three properties you actually need for the next twelve months.
Where founders systematically mis-model
Hire comparisons usually stop at salary, which understates the real cost by about 26% once statutory load and recruiting are included. Agency comparisons usually stop at the retainer, which understates the coordination cost. AI comparisons usually assume zero human time. This engine prices all three omissions explicitly so the three numbers are genuinely comparable.
Is it cheaper to hire or use an agency in India?
Below roughly ₹12L of annual scope, an agency usually wins: the recruiting cost and the first six months of ramp are too heavy for a small workload. Above ₹25L of scope, a hire wins on cost by year two and by 30–40% by year three. The crossover sits where the agency markup exceeds the hire's amortised recruiting and ramp cost, which is roughly ₹18–22L of annual scope for a mid-senior role.
What is the real cost of an employee beyond salary?
Add 16–20% for statutory contributions — 12% PF, 4.81% gratuity, ESI where applicable and insurance — plus about 8.33% of first-year CTC in recruiting, plus equipment and software, plus the management hours your own time is worth. The true first-year cost of a ₹18L hire is close to ₹24L, and the true three-year cost including management is closer to ₹72L.
Can AI actually replace a hire?
It replaces tasks, not roles. For well-specified, high-volume work with a clear definition of done — copy variants, first-draft design, data extraction, code scaffolding — an AI stack plus a part-time senior supervisor genuinely substitutes. For work that requires judgment under ambiguity, stakeholder trust, or accountability for a decision, it does not, and the supervision cost quietly becomes a hire anyway.
How do I price the management tax?
Take the hours per week you spend hiring, reviewing, unblocking and retaining, and multiply by your own internal hourly rate. Founders consistently estimate this at zero and then wonder why their calendar is full. A typical full-time hire consumes 3 to 5 founder hours a week in a company under 20 people.
When should I switch from agency to in-house?
When the work is continuous, when the agency is learning the same context for the third time, and when you have enough scope to keep a specialist fully loaded. The practical trigger is simple: if you have been renewing an agency retainer for more than nine months and the scope has not shrunk, you have already paid for the hire's recruiting cost.
This is a cost model, not a hiring recommendation. Output quality, IP ownership, confidentiality and continuity differ materially between the three paths and are not priced here.
Zero data leaves your browser. Inputs are never transmitted, never logged, never sold. The only network request this page makes is for a font it already cached.
Indicative model only. Not financial, tax or legal advice. Benchmarks are directional. Verify decisions with a qualified professional.